Friday, August 31, 2007


Craig’s a Liar from the ‘Hood’ Too

Earl Ofari Hutchinson

Minneapolis airport police Sgt. Dave Karsnia has taken some heat for maybe being a little too zealous in putting the collar on so many guys that get their sexual kicks off with other men in public restrooms at the Minneapolis airport. But most say he is a diligent, upstanding, young cop that does his duty as he sees it. So it’s curious that Karsnia lectured Idaho Senator Larry Craig about lying and added that that’s what he’d expect from the guy we get out of the ‘hood.’ Now Karsnia is confronting a respected, GOP Senator on his lewd act, and his lame defense of it, but why did the comparison of Craig to the guy from the ‘hood’ so easily roll out of his mouth. It didn’t seem to fit. Or did it?


From what’s on the tape, Craig didn’t dispute the characterization. And in the tortuous public gyrations he’s gone through to try and explain what he did or didn’t do in the men’s bathroom, he made no reference to the reprimand. But way should he? There’s absolutely no way that Craig would ever compare himself to a guy from the hood. But could he be? The answer is yes and no. Legions of white men, and that includes wealthy, prominent, high positioned white men, have been indicted and jailed for lying to judges, grand juries, congressional committees, FBI and Justice Department investigators. Over the years, the white men that run government agencies from the White House to the FBI have been repeatedly caught in lie after lie to cover-up their misdeeds or blatant criminal wrongdoing. So it’s no stretch to compare men such as Craig to the guy from the ‘hood.’


The problem with that and here’s the no part, the comparison insults the mythical guy from the ‘hood. But he is very real to Karsnia because he fits in snugly public beliefs, or to be more precise, stereotypes about the ‘hood.’ The stereotype fits even more snugly when it’s jammed next to negative public perceptions and fears of black crime. When some young blacks turned to gangs, guns and drugs, and terrorized their communities, much of the press titillated the public with endless features on the crime-prone, crack-plagued, blood-stained streets of the ghetto.
TV action news crews and cop pseudo reality shows have turned that stereotype into a major growth industry, stalking black neighborhoods and filming busts for nightly news. The explosion of gangster rap and the spate of Hollywood ghetto films have convinced many Americans that the thug lifestyle was the black lifestyle. They have ghastly visions of the guy from the ‘hood’ heading for their neighborhoods next.


This racially disfigured view of blacks as inherent crooks and liars doesn’t change even when the actual crime figures don’t square with that perception. A few years ago researchers at the University of Wisconsin actually compared white views of neighborhood crime with actual figures from police reports and victimization surveys in three cities - Chicago, Baltimore and Seattle. They found huge a gap between public perception of the crime threat and the reality of it. The perceived severity of the crime problem fluctuated with the number of young African-American men nearby - more so than with any other neighborhood factor, including the actual crime rate.


The skewed perception of crime and blacks has also deeply colored how judges and juries perceive and decide criminal cases when the defendant is as Karsnia put it a guy from the ‘hood.’ A 2003 Penn State University study found that many whites are likely to associate pictures of blacks with violent crimes, and in some cases where crimes were not committed by blacks they misidentified the perpetrator as an African-American.


The prevailing notion of who’s a crook and a liar and who isn’t has also spilled over into the job market. In 2005 Researchers at Princeton University surveyed nearly 1,500 private employers in New York City. They found that black men with no criminal records were no more likely to find work than white men with criminal records. In another study of employer attitudes toward minority hiring, some employers didn’t even try too hide the reason they were reluctant or refused to hire the guy from the ‘hood.’ They flatly described blacks as "unskilled," "uneducated," "illiterate." "dishonest," "lacked initiative," "unmotivated," "involved with gangs and drugs," "did not understand work," "unstable," "lacked charm," "had no family values," and were "poor role models."


The last reason they gave for slamming the employment door on blacks was especially apt in relation to Karsnia’s reprimand of Craig. He was righteously offended that a senator could so abuse his name and reputation by stooping to commit a petty criminal act in a men’s restroom. That immediately disqualified him as any kind of fit model for decency. In that instant whether Karsnia knew it or not, and could admit it or not, Craig was the fictional guy from the ‘hood.’


Earl Ofari Hutchinson is an author and political analyst. His new book The Latino Challenge to Black America: Towards a Conversation between African-Americans and Hispanics (Middle Passage Press and Hispanic Economics New York) in English and Spanish will be out in October.

6 comments:

stifs said...

I didn't think it could have been done. My brother, you have a taken a news topic way from left field and found a hook to connect with problems with and perceptions of Black America. Honestly, I see no reason to connect this story with anything involving Black America. The comment "hood" in certain midwest cities can be black, white, hispanic, and possibly asian. A person from the hood is not solely black. You must have been running lean on stories to write near a publishing deadline...I guess.

Brazelton-Moseley Inc said...

The Hutchinson report has always covered topics from a perspective of people of color. And while I, in no way need to speak for the brother I feel the message is clear, the perception of the young African American is tainted due to the style and culture that is in vogue today. Furthermore it hurts to be in public where we simply show our lack of concern of dress, speech and other issues that is thought by some to be hip, but in reality foster hostle stereotypes that will take generations to destroy.
True, a person from the hood does not have to be Black. Hell we all know that. So get past that and take a real look at perception.
If you can't, well I wish you luck in the future.
If there is one for old Hip Hoppers.

Anonymous said...

ACCORDING TO WHO YOU HEAR ABOUT THE LARRY CRAIG INCIDENT. THE GOP SUPPOSE TO BE THE PARTY OF FAMILY VALUES AND GOOD MORALS AND WHEN THE COP LECTURED CRAIG HE SEEM UPSET THAT THIS GUY WAS DOING WHATEVER IN THE RESTROOM.SO WHEN THE HE WAS CAUGHT AND HE WAS LYING TO COVER UP HIS MIS DEEDS THE COP LOOK AT IT AS A BLACK GUY FROM THE HOOD LYING ABOUT CRIME.

ekphill1 said...

In regards to stifs
I read your blog and I have a few simple questions. How many BLIND black slaves do you think there where in this country? Master probably wouldn't kill them because they could be led to pick cotton. DO you think because they never saw the master they didn't know they were slaves? They were as much a slave as the ones that could see. If you sat him in a room with the master's children, he would still know he/she was a slave. By action and voice we are reminded that we are the BOYS in the hood! The primary words here being "BOYS & HOOD” We are still not respected by America as a whole, especially in the halls of law enforcement. You don't need to hear it or see it to know it to know where you stand.
The reference is the hood! We are the devil in the hood. We are the people that occupy the "BAD" side of our metropolitan cities. The bad side of the city usually means the black side. Black men are the boogeyman and commit all kinds of crimes.
Hell we even make movies about it.

You comment that the hood in Midwest cities can be black, white, Hispanic, and possibly Asian. A person from the hood is not solely black. I was born and raised in Chicago.
Every bad part of town is usually full of minorities I will give you that. If you go to the city lock up at Cook County Jail BLACK is the predominate race. Go to Joliet Prison BLACK is the predominate race. There are many hoods. But the one that got the most acclaim in Chicago for years was Cabrini Green and most all the tenants were black.
This rings the same for most cities. I was stationed in Aurora, Colorado just outside of Denver the home of the Columbine massacre. The worst place to go in Denver was Colfax Street. You know why? Blacks and Hispanics lived there. thus it was called the “hood” because of all the “bad elements”.

Here is the real question? Are all black Americans evil sexual deviants that hang out in men’s bathrooms? NO. You would not know that from the transcripts. Blacks are deviants to this officer and that was one of the points that Earl was trying to make.

My 70 year old grandfather always says that no one ever had to convince him that this country thinks he is a N*gger. We are not even a generation outside of the civil rights movement. Racist ideology and belief are in our lives everyday. Racist can’t just come up and call you a N*gger to your face anymore. They use a more subtle way of saying what they mean. We have to be careful not to fall into a Pavlov's dog mentality where we become so accustomed to the new racist behavior that we ignore comments like "guy in the hood" if you don't think that the officers comment was in reference to blacks you are already hearing the bell and reacting to white America’s programmed responses.

Anonymous said...

I thought that our "first Black President" Bill Clinton made it okay for white men caught doing stupid, deviant, and illegal ish to be called a black man in a round-a-bout way.

Once that trend started there's no where to go but downhill.

Half of the murder victims in this country are black, and they are killed by other blacks. That is a very serious crime problem, something that white people can't be blamed for.

Anonymous said...

tibia money tibia gold tibia item runescape accounts buy runescape accounts runescape money runescape gold runescape gp runescape power leveling runescape powerleveling cheap rs2 powerleveling runescape equipment buy rs equipment runescape runes cheap rs2 runes runescape logs cheap rs2 logs runescape items buy runescape items runescape quest point rs2 quest point cheap runescape questpoint runescape gold runescape items runescape power leveling runescape money runescape gold buy runescape gold buy runescape money runescape items runescape accounts runescape gp runescape accounts runescape money runescape power leveling runescape powerleveling tibia gold dofus kamas buy dofus kamas wow power leveling wow powerleveling runescape questpoint rs2 questpoint Warcraft PowerLeveling Warcraft Power Leveling World of Warcraft PowerLeveling World of Warcraft Power Leveling Hellgate money Hellgate gold buy runescape logs buy rs2 items cheap runescape items Hellgate London gold Guild Wars Gold buy Guild Wars Gold runescape items rs2 accounts cheap rs2 equipments lotro gold buy lotro gold buy runescape money buy runescape gold buy runescape runes lotro gold buy lotro gold runescape money runescape gold cheap rs2 powerleveling eve isk eve online isk buy runescape power leveling rs2 power leveling tibia gold tibia item runescape accounts Fiesta Silver Fiesta Gold SilkRoad Gold buy SilkRoad Gold Scions of Fate Gold Hellgate Palladium Hellgate London Palladium SOF Gold Age Of Conan Gold AOC Gold ArchLord gold tibia money tibia gold runescape accounts runescape gold cheap rs2 powerleveling buy ArchLord gold DDO Plat Dungeons and Dragons Online Plat